Eleas LeRoux
Avatar:
VW: Second Life

Location: Troy, NY
Country: US
Donate to LHVW

Life: Spontaneous or Generative?

user image 2010-07-01
By: Eleas LeRoux
Posted in:
Eleas LeRoux, Year of Our Lord 178_

Among the great questions of our age is that to do with the origins of life. We call this the question of abiogenesis, of origins, of beginnings.

Does life arise all around us all the time, from nothing? The theory that it does is called 'spontaneous generation' or 'equivocal generation'. Aristotle is among its proponents, and it has been the prevailing paradigm for two thousand years. When asked for proof, the most common example used is that of, with apologies to anyone disturbed by the image, maggots. These larvae seem to appear from nowhere at a certain point in the decay of meats. In the 17th and 18th-century scientific communities ((the question is more or less laid to rest by the end of 19th century with the fine work of Louis Pasteur)), this question is still open. Many of us have come to believe, at least, that not all life is spontaneously generated ... we know that many forms of life, including our own, have parents, i.e. is generative.

The late Francesco Redi, a Tuscan Renaissance man, poet, academician, physician to the legendary house of De' Medici, less than one hundred years ago conducted precise and methodical experiments to do with abiogenesis. He placed objects in jars, including fish and meat, and covered half of said jars with gauze, leaving the others open to the air. He observed that when flies could enter the jars, presumably to deposit their eggs, maggots would soon appear. When the jars were covered, the fish and meats would rot or dry out without any other effects. He then tried placing dead flies and live flies in jars, noting that the live flies produced maggots and the dead ones did not. After many careful experiments, he concluded that life comes from life -- not from the ether, but from parents of some kind, even when those parents are unseen to us.

There are still those, however, who argue that life can come from dung or air. They explain Redi's and other's experiments by explaining that jars restrict the flow of air, and covered jars restrict that flow further.

Given my recent experiments with optics, and my observation of insects, larva, and eggs, I am further convinced that life is not spontaneous, that it is generative. I cannot prove that there is no life that does not simply appear, but I believe that any life must have some heritage, that where there is life there are parents from whom it springs.

~Eleas LeRoux


Docteur Panacek
02 Jul 2010 09:48:18AM @docteur-panacek:
Very interesting dear Eleas. Did you already heard of the experiments that john Needham is doing in England? He is the first Priest that has become a member of the Royal Society of London for the Improvement of Natural Knowledge. His experiments on boiled broths favor the process of spontaneous generation, although i doubt his methods.It will be fun discussing these at the next Coeur fair. It seems we are going to be neighbors there.Greetings, Pekel.
Eleas LeRoux
02 Jul 2010 12:38:40PM @eleas-leroux:
Thank you both for your comments. I have heard of Fr. John Needham's experiments, yes, and I'm not certain what to make of them. I suspect much depends on the time and temperature of boiling -- I would like to have more information about these in Needham's experiments. A colleague in Modena writes to me that he hears quite opposite ideas from a Fr. Lazzaro Spallanzani there whose experiments yield a very different result. Frankly, I would not have the courage to write much on this if it were not for my colleague's report, as I would not want to seem to contradict the Roman church's doctrine in my inquiries. It is difficult enough to keep my Reformed Church heritage apart from my professional life as it is ... I do not want to be seen as spreading a heresy. When these two gentlemen of the cloth disagree, however, I feel I may speak as my observations warrant with relative safety.
Eleas LeRoux
02 Jul 2010 12:40:14PM @eleas-leroux:
Oh, and yes, my darling Mme. Lytton has agreed to come to the Faire. I do so look forward to her company.
Lord Myron de Verne
02 Jul 2010 12:52:40PM @lord-myron-de-verne:
Well, experiments on boiling broths at the Coeur Fair?There's always a new thing happening there every month!Nevertheless, I suggest that we have rather some Fruit Punch boiling in a bowl for this experiment: if it fails, at least we can drink it next, according to this well-established tradition of our Fairs!
Lord Myron de Verne
02 Jul 2010 12:55:44PM @lord-myron-de-verne:
It seems sometimes I can't take anything seriously:)but that's wrong. I am really interested in this research about the arisal of life.You have to tell us more:)